Question 1

It is fairly important to use large value resistors (10 MΩ works well) for resistors R1 and R2, as well as a comparator with high input impedance (a TL08x operational amplifier with JFET inputs is fine). Explain why.


Question 2

Suppose a student builds this circuit, using 10 MΩ resistors for R1 and R2, and a 22 μF capacitor for C1, and finds that he must frequently adjust the potentiometer to keep the circuit at a reasonable level of sensitivity. A fellow student has encountered and overcome this same problem, and offers to fix the first student’s circuit by replacing the 22 μF capacitor with something much smaller: a 0.001 μF (1 nF) capacitor.

Now, the modified circuit responds predictably. No longer must the student frequently adjust the potentiometer to achieve the desired sensitivity. Explain why a change in capacitance made such a difference, and what the problem was in the original circuit (with the much larger capacitor).


Question 3

Modify the circuit shown to use a 555 monostable timer instead of a J-K flip-flop at the output of the comparator.

Also, explain the significance of reversing the comparator’s input connections (as compared to the schematic shown on the front page of this worksheet). Why is it better to do this, if we are triggering a monostable 555 timer circuit?


Published under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution License